Ablation, or the use of high-frequency electromagnetic (EM) energy to destroy soft-tissue tumors, has been in existence for a few decades, but in recent years its underlying technology has evolved.
The benchmark of minimally invasive tissue treatment has long been the application of electrical current to kill abnormal tissues. This is done by heating tissues until they break down, a process called thermal ablation. Energy is delivered at 500 kHz, within the radio frequency (RF) range of the EM spectrum, hence these systems are called RF ablation systems.
In recent years, microwave (MW) ablation technology has also become commercially available and increasingly popular. At MW frequencies, oscillating EM fields are utilized to perform thermal ablation. Medtronic plc, Dublin, Ireland, one of the world’s premier medical technology and services companies, is a leader in both RF and microwave ablation technologies. With both RF and MW systems, the energy for ablation is applied using one or more needle-like probes.
Medtronic’s latest innovation, the Emprint™ ablation system with Thermosphere™ technology, offers more predictable and repeatable results than other techniques and devices (See Figure 1). These advantages come from the fact that Thermosphere™ technology enables precise control of an EM field independent of the surrounding tissue environment.
Striving for Better Predictability
According to research, physicians rate predictability as their number one concern with ablation performance. The higher the level of predictability, the easier it is for a physician to plan a treatment procedure that will be safer, more effective, and less time-consuming.
Because of its nature, it’s challenging to be certain that RF ablation procedures will achieve the desired results. Given their different electrical conductivities, some tissues are less amenable to effective RF heating than others. Moreover, as the temperature in targeted tissue approaches 100°C, water in the tissue begins to vaporize and electrical conductivity rapidly decreases. This can make it difficult to generate temperatures high enough to cause cell breakdown.
MW ablation technology attempts to overcome these limitations by using an EM field radiated into the tissue (See Figure 2). However, in practical application, tissue type and the vaporization of water during ablation cause the size and shape of the EM field to vary.
The Emprint™ ablation system with Thermosphere™ technology realizes the promise of predictability. It gives physicians the ability to easily control the thermal energy delivered by allowing precise control of the EM field across tissues and temperatures. This allows clinicians to accurately predict the boundaries and characteristics of the ablation zone.
Real-Time Monitoring of Ablations
“The challenge now is to monitor the ablation performance in real-time,” said Casey Ladtkow, principal engineer in the Early Technologies unit of Medtronic’s Minimally Invasive Therapies Group (MITG). “At present, when performing ablations, physicians don’t have continuous real-time feedback on the effectiveness of their procedure. If they could know exactly what is happening in real-time from start to finish, the effectiveness of ablation treatment would increase,” he said.
With some 40 staff members focused on interventional oncology, the mission of his unit is to deliver procedural solutions that alleviate pain, restore health, and extend life. Ladtkow and his team are using COMSOL Multiphysics® software to develop new ablation probes in order to achieve even higher levels of predictable performance and effectiveness.
One development-stage project is to optimize the design of these probes so they can both create a more precise ablation zone and also provide real-time feedback using radiometers.
Radiometers measure EM radiation and enable the characterization of the spatial distribution of an EM field. Ladtkow’s team is incorporating radiometers into Medtronic probes in order to give clinicians real-time feedback about the ablation zone. This will enable a clinician to fine-tune the zone as needed during the procedure, and to make sure the radiation destroys the targeted tissues while minimizing effects on the surrounding healthy tissue. (See Figure 2)
The team uses Multiphysics and its RF Module to help them model the probes and better understand and optimize their emitting/radiating and receiving/monitoring properties. “The performance and accuracy of MW ablation systems are affected by a number of dynamic factors that arise simultaneously in multiple physics domains. COMSOL software gives us the ability to perform the relevant complex modeling quickly and easily, to help us understand these coupled effects and improve our design,” Ladtkow said.